still keeping a paper log after all these years

Been at this since before you could pull a quote without calling somebody. Figured I'd share how I actually use data day to day, since I see a lot of folks here drowning in indicators. Every morning I write three things on a legal pad. Not in an app, on paper. First, what I think the general tone is, risk on, risk off, or nobody home. Second, the levels I care about on the two or three names I actually follow. Third, and this is the one that saved my hide more times than I can count, what would have to happen for me to be wrong. That third line is the whole exercise. Anybody can find a chart that agrees with them. Took me about fifteen years and one very expensive lesson in the early 2000s to understand that the data doesn't tell you what to do, it tells you whether the story you already believed is still holding up. When I stopped writing that line down I started holding losers, every single time. There's a direct line between the discipline of writing it and the discipline of acting on it. I also only look at volume and price. That's it. I tried the whole zoo over the years — every oscillator that came out, I ran it. What I found is that more inputs mostly gave me more excuses. When six things disagree you'll pick the one that says buy. Two things that disagree just means sit on your hands, and sitting on your hands is a position. One more thing on data quality. Crypto folks especially, know where your numbers come from and which venue. I've watched people make decisions off a thin book and wonder why the fill was nowhere near the screen. That's not the market cheating you, that's just not knowing what you were looking at. Curious what everybody else's morning actually looks like. Not the version you'd post, the real one.
GrandpaGrizzly
16 posts · 0 followers
+ Follow

Related reading

5 replies

ZenTrader_Ana· Jun 2026 ago
that third line is really a psychological tool more than an analytical one, isn't it. writing down what would make you wrong gives your future self permission to exit without it feeling like a personal failure. i do something similar but out loud, and honestly paper sounds better.
R
RiskFirstRita· Jun 2026 ago· edited Aug 2026 ago
The "sitting on your hands is a position" line deserves to be on a poster. My pre-market checklist has a similar item, if I can't state the invalidation in one sentence, the trade doesn't get sized, period. Would add one line to yours if you'll allow it: what you'd lose if the invalidation gaps past you overnight, because knowing where you're wrong and knowing what wrong costs are two different pieces of homework.
F
FiveMinFiona· Jul 2026 ago
My real morning is less noble than my written one. Coffee, then I mark the overnight range and the prior day's close on my 5m, and that's the whole prep. The invalidation line I do keep, but I'll admit I sometimes write it after I'm already in, which is basically cheating myself. Going to move it before entry.
N
NightOwl_Yuki· Jul 2026 ago
the thin book thing is my whole life lol. overnight the same pair can look completely different across venues and if you're staring at one chart you just don't see it. i keep two open for that reason. also +1 on paper, i write my level on a sticky note on the monitor so i can't pretend later i had a different plan
Q
QuietVol· Jul 2026 ago· edited Aug 2026 ago
The point about six inputs producing excuses is really a selection problem, if you sample enough weakly correlated signals, one of them agrees with your prior almost by construction. Adding indicators doesn't add information at that stage, it just widens the menu. Do you find your two-input rule holds up in very quiet stretches, or does price and volume alone leave you flat for long periods?
Sign in to reply →
← All market data & research