cut my bot down to one setup and i sleep better

background. used to scalp manually. burned out. now i automate. last year i had four setups running. gap continuation, mean revert on the open, a trend follow thing, and a late day fade. all of them tuned. all of them fine on paper. problem was i couldn't tell which one was doing what. bad week comes, i can't tell if the fade is broken or if the gap logic is just in a rough patch. so i tinker with all four. classic. by month end none of them are the thing i tested. killed three. kept gap continuation. only setup i actually understand at the bar by bar level, meaning i can look at a fill and say yes that was supposed to happen, or no that was a bug. what changed in my process: one. i log intent before the session, not after. two lines. what am i expecting the bot to do today, what would make me shut it off. shutting it off is a decision, so it needs a rule, otherwise it's a mood. two. i review fills, not pnl. pnl is noisy for months. fills tell me tomorrow if entry logic is drifting. three. no changes midweek. period. i keep a notes file. friday i look at it. most ideas look dumb by friday. the ones that don't get tested properly on old data first. four. size is fixed for a full quarter. i used to bump size after good stretches without admitting it. that's not a strategy, that's a feeling. downside is boredom. i'm not lying about that. one setup means most days nothing interesting happens and i just watch logs. old me would have added something just to have a reason to sit at the desk. anyone else run a single setup on purpose. or is everyone still stacking.
G
GapHunterMike
17 posts · 0 followers
+ Follow

Related reading

3 replies

S
SpreadWatcher· Aug 2026 ago
reviewing fills instead of pnl is the right call, that's where the rot shows first. i'd add one thing: log the spread at entry alongside the fill, not just the fill price. drift in your average entry is sometimes not your logic changing at all, it's the conditions you're getting filled in changing, and those two look identical if you only keep the price.
L
LurkerLee· Aug 2026 ago
how long did it take before killing the other three stopped feeling like a mistake?
C
CoffeeAndCharts· Aug 2026 ago
the fixed size for a whole quarter one hit me right in the chest, i absolutely do the quiet bump after a good stretch and then act surprised when a normal drawdown feels enormous. also fully with you on the boredom thing, i think half the extra setups people run exist so there's something to look at in the morning rather than because they earned a slot. writing down what would make you shut it off before the session is going straight into my routine, thanks mike.
Sign in to reply →
← All automated trading